Physics
What happens to the entropy of two photons absorbed by an ideal photovoltaic cell powering an ideal LED that emits them as one lower entropy photon?
Step-by-step physics solution: What happens to the entropy of two photons absorbed by an ideal photovoltaic cell powering an ideal LED that emits them as o
As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. For more practice problems like this, see Schaum’s Outline of College Physics, 12th Edition.
1. Restatement of the Problem in Plain Language
The student is proposing a clever thought experiment: Can we violate the Second Law of Thermodynamics by taking two photons of a certain energy, absorbing them in an ideal photovoltaic (PV) cell, sending the resulting electrical energy through a lossless superconductor to an ideal LED, and having the LED emit a single photon with twice the energy?
Because a single photon of higher energy actually has lower thermodynamic entropy than two photons of half that energy (carrying the same total energy), the student is asking:
- If this process can theoretically be done reversibly (with zero heat generation), how does the total entropy of the universe not decrease?
- Where is the hidden entropy generation that protects the Second Law of Thermodynamics?
2. Step-by-Step Thermodynamic Analysis
To resolve this paradox, we must analyze the thermodynamic entropy of radiation and the operation of ideal semiconductor devices (PV cells and LEDs) under strict thermodynamic equilibrium.
Step A: Defining the Thermodynamic Entropy of Radiation
The entropy of a beam of light (or a photon gas) depends not just on its energy, but on its temperature (frequency) and its concentration (chemical potential).
When we say “two photons of energy $E$,” we are describing radiation with a specific spectral radiance. When we convert them into “one photon of energy $2E$,” we are altering the frequency of the radiation field.
Step B: The Thermodynamic Limit of a Photovoltaic Cell
A photovoltaic cell does not just “absorb light and make electricity.” It is an energy converter operating between a radiation source (the sun or a light source at temperature $T_s$) and an ambient sink (at temperature $T_0$).
An ideal, reversible PV cell satisfies the detailed balance limit (the Shockley-Queisser limit in its thermodynamic formulation). For a PV cell to absorb incident photons without generating internal entropy, it must operate such that the chemical potential of the electron-hole pairs generated ($\mu$) is related to the voltage $V$ by: \(eV = \mu = E_{\text{gap}}\)
However, a PV cell is bathed in ambient thermal radiation. To maintain reversibility (zero entropy production), the net entropy change of the universe $\Delta S_{\text{universe}}$ must be zero. The entropy of the incoming radiation, the outgoing recombination radiation, and the heat transferred must balance out exactly.
Step C: Analyzing the Energy and Entropy Balance
Let’s look at the student’s premise: Two photons of energy $E$ are absorbed to emit one photon of energy $2E$.
- Energy Conservation:
- Input: $2 \text{ photons each of energy } E \implies \text{Total Energy} = 2E$.
- Output: $1 \text{ photon of energy } 2E \implies \text{Total Energy} = 2E$. Energy is conserved.
- Photon Number and Statistical Mechanics (Phase Space):
- This is where the paradox breaks down. Light is a collection of bosons. The entropy of a radiation field is fundamentally tied to the number of available quantum states (phase space volume) the photons can occupy.
- A beam of two independent photons occupies more phase space states than a single photon of twice the frequency. Specifically, combining two photons into one decreases the statistical entropy associated with the photon number distribution.
Step D: Why the “Ideal” 2-to-1 Conversion is Thermodynamically Impossible
The student assumes an “ideal” LED can emit a photon of energy $2E$ from two electrons/holes of energy $E$ reversibly. But let’s look at the chemical potentials:
- To emit a photon of energy $2E$, the LED’s band gap must be $E_{\text{gap, LED}} = 2E$.
- To absorb photons of energy $E$, the PV cell’s band gap must be $E_{\text{gap, PV}} = E$.
If you connect a PV cell with band gap $E$ to an LED with band gap $2E$ via a superconductor:
- The PV cell generates a maximum voltage of $V = E/e$.
- The LED requires a minimum voltage of $V = 2E/e$ to inject carriers across its $2E$ band gap and cause recombination resulting in a $2E$ photon.
The mismatch: A voltage of $E/e$ cannot drive a current into a device requiring $2E/e$ without an external power source supplying the missing energy (and therefore entropy). If you try to run current backward or force the system, the LED will simply not emit $2E$ photons; at best, it will absorb the voltage and sit in open-circuit voltage, or thermalize.
If you attempt to circumvent this by using multi-junction physics or upconversion, thermodynamics dictates that the process requires either:
- An external work input, or
- Thermal contact with a heat bath at a temperature higher than the radiation temperature, generating entropy to compensate for the “decrease” in photon entropy.
Specifically, the absorption and emission processes in semiconductors are governed by Kirchhoff’s Law of thermal radiation for luminescent devices ($\text{Emission} \propto \text{Absorption} \times \text{Occupancy Factors}$). To emit a higher-energy photon than what is locally supported by the incoming chemical potential, the system must extract thermal energy (entropy) from the lattice (phonons) at temperature $T$.
Thus, either:
- The process is impossible because voltage/chemical potential cannot be stepped up passively through a superconductor without violating conservation of energy/charge.
- If thermal phonons are absorbed from the lattice to make up the energy/entropy deficit, the lattice cools down, generating entropy in the environment (heat transfer from ambient), which guarantees $\Delta S_{\text{universe}} \ge 0$.
3. Final Answer
No, the Second Law of Thermodynamics is not violated, and entropy does not mysteriously vanish.
The proposed setup is fundamentally impossible for two reasons:
- Voltage/Chemical Potential Mismatch: A PV cell with a band gap matching energy $E$ cannot generate the chemical potential (voltage) required to drive an LED with a band gap of $2E$. Passive components like superconductors cannot step up voltages.
- Phase Space and Thermal Balancing: If such a process were forced using ambient thermal fluctuations (phonons), the system would have to absorb thermal heat from its environment. The entropy required to compress two photon states into one higher-energy photon state is exactly supplied by the thermal entropy extracted from the lattice/environment, ensuring that the net entropy change of the universe is always greater than or equal to zero ($\Delta S_{\text{universe}} \ge 0$).
4. Common Mistakes for This Problem Type
- Confusing Energy with Entropy: Assuming that because energy is conserved ($2 \times E = 1 \times 2E$), entropy must also be conserved. Entropy depends on the state (frequency, polarization, spatial distribution, and occupation number) of the particles, not just their total energy sum.
- Treating Photons Like Classical Particles: Forgetting that photons are bosons. The entropy of light is governed by Bose-Einstein statistics. Compressing the number of photons (reducing the photon flux while keeping energy constant) drastically reduces the statistical entropy of the radiation field, which must be compensated for by an entropy increase elsewhere in the system (e.g., heat rejected to the environment).
- Ignoring Detailed Balance: Assuming semiconductor band gaps can be mixed and matched in circuits without accounting for the chemical potentials ($\mu_c - \mu_v = eV$) that govern carrier recombination and photon emission.
Original question: What happens to the entropy of two photons absorbed by an ideal photovoltaic cell powering an ideal LED that emits them as one lower entropy photon? on Physics Stack Exchange, licensed CC BY-SA.