Physics
Does this break the laws of conservation?
Step-by-step physics solution: Does this break the laws of conservation?
As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. For more practice problems like this, see Schaum’s Outline of College Physics, 12th Edition.
1. Restate What’s Being Asked in Plain Language
The student is asking whether a specific mechanical device violates the laws of thermodynamics (specifically, the conservation of energy).
The proposed device consists of a bicycle wheel containing:
- A primary weight that starts at the top ($0^\circ$).
- A track along which this weight falls.
- A 1:1 exact counterbalance located $180^\circ$ opposite the weight.
- No external energy sources (no springs, elastic bands, or motors).
The core question is: Can this system cause a weight to fall and then rise higher on the opposite side than its starting point, without adding any outside energy, thus creating a perpetual motion machine?
2. Step-by-Step Physics Analysis
To determine if this system violates the laws of physics, let us analyze it using the principles of classical mechanics and the conservation of energy.
Step 1: Identify the relevant physical law
The First Law of Thermodynamics is the law of conservation of energy. It states that energy cannot be created or destroyed in an isolated system. For a purely mechanical system operating in a conservative gravitational field, the total mechanical energy ($E$) is the sum of kinetic energy ($K$) and potential energy ($U$): \(E = K + U = \text{constant}\)
Step 2: Analyze the gravitational potential energy of the primary weight
Let the center of the bicycle wheel be at height $h = 0$, and let the radius of the wheel/track be $R$.
- The weight starts at the top ($0^\circ$). Its initial height is $y_i = +R$, and its initial gravitational potential energy is: \(U_i = mgR\)
- As the weight falls along the track to the lowest point ($180^\circ$), it loses potential energy.
- As it rises on the opposite side, it converts that kinetic energy back into potential energy.
- Without an external force adding energy to the system, the maximum height ($y_f$) the weight can possibly reach on the other side is limited by the initial energy: \(mg y_f \le mg y_i \implies y_f \le R\)
Step 3: Account for the counterbalance
The student mentions a “1:00 counterbalance exactly $180^\circ$ opposite of the weight.”
- A $1:1$ counterbalance means an equal mass is placed at the exact opposite side of the wheel.
- In a symmetrical wheel where a weight and its exact counterbalance are connected rigidly through the center (like a standard symmetric wheel or lever), the center of mass of the system remains at the center of the wheel, or moves in a fixed, predictable periodic path.
- Adding a counterbalance does not create energy; in fact, a 1:1 counterbalance moving in opposition simply balances the torques. If weight A goes down, weight B goes up by the exact same amount.
- The system is completely symmetric. The potential energy gained by the counterweight going up equals the potential energy lost by the falling weight (ignoring the details of the track, assuming they are rigidly linked or balanced).
Step 4: Account for real-world energy losses (Friction and Drag)
In any physical setup:
- There is friction at the axle/hub.
- There is air resistance (drag).
- There is friction between the weight and the track.
These non-conservative forces constantly convert mechanical energy into thermal energy (heat). Therefore, the actual height the weight would reach on the other side will be strictly less than $R$ ($y_f < R$).
Step 5: Evaluate the claim of rising “higher”
For the weight to rise higher than where it fell from (i.e., $y_f > R$), the final potential energy would have to be greater than the initial potential energy ($U_f > U_i$) without any work being done on the system by an external agent ($W_{\text{ext}} = 0$).
According to the Work-Energy Theorem: \(\Delta E_{\text{mechanical}} = W_{\text{non-conservative}}\) Since $W_{\text{non-conservative}} \le 0$ (due to friction) and no external motor or force is applied, $\Delta E_{\text{mechanical}}$ must be less than or equal to zero. It is mathematically impossible for $\Delta E_{\text{mechanical}} > 0$.
3. Final Answer
Yes, this setup—if it actually behaved the way described—would violate the laws of conservation of energy (specifically the First Law of Thermodynamics).
However, in reality, the device does not work. The weight will not rise higher than its starting point. Because of friction, air resistance, and the fundamental constraints of gravity and conservation of energy, the weight will actually rise to a height lower than its starting point and eventually come to a complete stop. This apparatus is a classic conceptual design for a failed perpetual motion machine of the first kind.
4. Common Mistakes for This Problem Type
- Confusing Torque Balance with Energy Creation: Students often assume that because a system is balanced or uses counterweights to make turning “easier,” it is generating surplus energy. A counterbalance only redistributes potential energy; it cannot create a net gain in energy.
- Ignoring Friction and Air Resistance: Many thought experiments assume an idealized “frictionless” world where energy is conserved, but students mistakenly take the next illogical step to assume energy can somehow increase beyond the initial starting amount in such idealizations.
- Misinterpreting Visual Symmetry for Mechanical Advantage: Symmetrical arrangements (like opposing weights on a wheel) often result in a net-zero torque or a closed conservative loop where inputs and outputs of energy perfectly cancel out, resulting in zero net work done over a full cycle.
Original question: Does this break the laws of conservation? on Physics Stack Exchange, licensed CC BY-SA.