Physics
Decrease in potential energy while connecting two conductors
Step-by-step physics solution: Decrease in potential energy while connecting two conductors
As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. For more practice problems like this, see Schaum’s Outline of College Physics, 12th Edition.
1. Restate What’s Being Asked in Plain Language
When two charged conducting spherical shells are connected by a conducting wire, charge flows until both spheres reach the same electric potential. During this process, the total electrostatic potential energy of the system decreases.
The student is asking: If the connecting wire has zero resistance ($R = 0$), how can energy be dissipated as heat if Joule’s law ($H = I^2 R t$) gives zero heat? Where does the lost potential energy actually go?
2. Step-by-Step Derivation and Explanation
Step 1: Analyze the Energy State Before and After Connection
Let two conducting spherical shells of radii $R_1$ and $R_2$ carry initial charges $Q_1$ and $Q_2$, respectively, and be placed far apart from each other (so we can ignore mutual capacitance effects).
-
Initial Potential Energy ($U_i$): \(U_i = \frac{1}{2} \frac{Q_1^2}{4\pi\varepsilon_0 R_1} + \frac{1}{2} \frac{Q_2^2}{4\pi\varepsilon_0 R_2}\)
-
Final State: When connected by a wire, charge flows until their electric potentials are equal ($V_1 = V_2 = V_f$). Let the new charges be $q_1$ and $q_2$, such that total charge is conserved: \(q_1 + q_2 = Q_1 + Q_2\)
-
Final Potential Energy ($U_f$): \(U_f = \frac{1}{2} \frac{q_1^2}{4\pi\varepsilon_0 R_1} + \frac{1}{2} \frac{q_2^2}{4\pi\varepsilon_0 R_2}\)
When you compute $\Delta U = U_f - U_i$, you find that $\Delta U < 0$ (energy is always lost/decreases), regardless of whether $R = 0$ in the wire.
Step 2: Address the Paradox of Zero Resistance ($R = 0$)
The student’s paradox relies on Joule’s heating formula: \(E_{\text{heat}} = \int I^2 R \, dt\) If $R = 0$, then $E_{\text{heat}} = 0$. How is energy lost if no heat is generated in the wire?
The resolution lies in the fact that real macroscopic wires always have inductance ($L$) and/or emission properties, and idealizing $R = 0$ in an electrodynamics problem creates a mathematical discontinuity.
Let us look at what physically happens when $R \to 0$:
-
Electromagnetic Radiation (The True Sink): When charges accelerate through the connecting wire from one sphere to the other, they constitute a time-varying electric current ($I(t)$). According to Maxwell’s equations, accelerating charges radiate electromagnetic waves.
Even if the resistance $R$ is strictly zero, the circuit possesses self-inductance ($L$). When the switch is closed, an LC-like oscillation occurs. The charge sloshes back and forth, but because energy is constantly carried away into space as electromagnetic radiation (radio waves/photons), the oscillation dampens until the system settles into its final electrostatic equilibrium. The “missing” potential energy is radiated away into the surrounding space.
-
Taking the Limit as $R \to 0$: What if we assume an ideal superconducting wire ($R = 0$) in a universe with no radiative losses (or instantaneous connection)?
If $R = 0$ and we ignore radiation, the current pulse is infinitely high ($I \to \infty$) for an infinitely short time ($\Delta t \to 0$). The product $I^2 R$ becomes a Dirac delta-like spike. Mathematically, the limit of $I^2 R$ as $R \to 0$ depends on how fast $I$ goes to infinity. In a real circuit, as $R$ decreases, the peak current increases, and 100% of the lost potential energy is converted into electromagnetic radiation (photons) rather than Joule heat.
3. Final Answer
The “lost” electrostatic potential energy is not lost to Joule heating if the wire has zero resistance; instead, it is radiated away into space as electromagnetic waves (photons) due to the acceleration of charges through the connecting wire.
As charge rushes from one conductor to the other, the changing current creates a transient electromagnetic field. Even with zero resistance ($R=0$), the system cannot settle into its new potential without shedding excess energy, which leaves the system in the form of radiation.
4. Common Mistakes
- Assuming $R = 0$ means no energy loss: Students often memorize $H = I^2Rt$ and assume that zero resistance means zero energy loss from the circuit. They forget that electrical energy can leave a circuit via radiation (Poynting vector), not just heat.
- Neglecting inductance and dynamics: Treating the connection as a purely static problem. Energy conservation requires looking at the process of charge transfer (dynamics), where charges accelerate, rather than just comparing the initial and final static states.
Original question: Decrease in potential energy while connecting two conductors on Physics Stack Exchange, licensed CC BY-SA.