Chemistry

Using Non-Harmonic reflections in warren averbach method

Step-by-step chemistry solution: Using Non-Harmonic reflections in warren averbach method

As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. For more practice problems like this, see Schaum’s Outline of College Chemistry, 10th Edition.


1. Restate the Problem in Plain Language

You are analyzing X-ray diffraction (XRD) data for Hydroxyapatite (HAp) using the Warren-Averbach method to determine crystallite size and microstrain. You want to know two main things:

  1. Can you include non-harmonic reflection peaks (peaks that do not belong to the same family of lattice planes, such as mixing $(hkl)$ reflections with different orders like $(100)$ and $(200)$ versus unrelated planes like $(100)$ and $(002)$), or must you stick strictly to harmonic reflections?
  2. What are the exact criteria for selecting reflection peaks when setting up a Warren-Averbach analysis?

2. Step-by-Step Solution

Step 1: Understand the Theoretical Basis of the Warren-Averbach Method

The Warren-Averbach (WA) method is a Fourier-based line profile analysis used to separate size broadening from strain broadening. It relies on the Fourier coefficients $A(L)$ of a diffraction peak, which are a product of the size coefficients $A^S(L)$ and the strain coefficients $A^D(L, g)$:

\[A(L) = A^S(L) \cdot A^D(L, g)\]

Where:

  • $L$ is the column length normal to the reflecting planes.
  • $g$ is the diffraction vector magnitude ($g = 2\sin\theta / \lambda$).

To separate size from strain, the method requires data from multiple orders of reflection from the same crystallographic plane family (i.e., harmonic reflections).


Step 2: Answer Part 1 — Can You Use Non-Harmonic Reflections?

No, you cannot use non-harmonic reflections for the core Warren-Averbach separation.

  • Why? Microstrain broadening is anisotropic (it depends heavily on the crystallographic direction $hkl$) and scales with the diffraction order ($g$). To separate size and strain mathematically, the size contribution $A^S(L)$ must remain constant while the strain contribution $A^D(L, g)$ varies with $g$.
  • If you compare reflections from completely different plane families (non-harmonic, e.g., comparing ${100}$ and ${002}$), the local elastic constants, dislocation densities, and strain fields are entirely different. Therefore, the assumption that only the $g$-vector magnitude changes while the defect structure remains identical breaks down entirely.

Step 3: Answer Part 2 — How to Properly Choose Peaks for Warren-Averbach

To execute a successful Warren-Averbach analysis on Hydroxyapatite (or any material), follow these strict selection rules:

  1. Select Harmonic Orders (Orders of the Same Peak): You need at least two (preferably three or more) orders of reflection from the same $(hkl)$ family.
    • Example for HAp (Hexagonal, $P6_3/m$): You can use the $(002)$ and $(004)$ peaks, or the $(300)$ and $(600)$ peaks.
  2. Check for Peak Overlap: Hydroxyapatite has a relatively low crystal symmetry (hexagonal), meaning many peaks overlap closely (e.g., the complex triplet around $2\theta = 30^\circ - 35^\circ$ consisting of $(211), (112), (300)$, etc.).
    • Rule: Do not use overlapping peaks unless you perform a rigorous Whole Powder Pattern Fitting (WPPF) or profile deconvolution first to isolate the individual peak shapes.
  3. Account for Instrumental Broadening (Standard): You must measure a strain-free reference standard (like well-annealed $\text{LaB}_6$ or $\text{Si}$) under identical instrumental conditions to subtract instrumental broadening using Stokes Fourier deconvolution before applying the WA method.

  4. Address Anisotropy (If Using Multiple Families): If you want to evaluate microstrain along different crystallographic directions (e.g., parallel vs. perpendicular to the $c$-axis in HAp), you must perform separate Warren-Averbach analyses on different harmonic sets (e.g., one analysis on ${002}-{004}$ and a separate analysis on ${300}-{600}$), and then combine them using anisotropic elasticity models (like the Voigt or Warren-Averbach-Krivoglad approach).

3. Final Answer

  1. Non-harmonic reflections cannot be mixed in a single Warren-Averbach calculation because microstrain is crystallographically anisotropic and varies between different plane families.
  2. Peak selection criteria: You must select harmonic reflections (multiple orders of the same $(hkl)$ family, such as ${002}$ and ${004}$), ensure the peaks are free from overlap (or properly deconvoluted), and use an instrumental standard to remove optics-related broadening prior to the Fourier analysis.

4. Common Mistakes

  • Mixing different $hkl$ indices in one plot: Plotting Fourier coefficients of $(100)$ against $(002)$ assuming they are just different $g$-values. This yields physically meaningless strain values because strain behavior differs drastically along the $a$-axis versus the $c$-axis in anisotropic materials like Hydroxyapatite.
  • Ignoring peak overlap: Using a peak that has a shoulder or hidden reflection nearby without performing profile fitting, which corrupts the Fourier coefficients.
  • Forgetting instrumental correction: Applying the Warren-Averbach method directly to raw, as-measured peaks without deconvoluting the instrumental broadening profile, leading to a severe underestimation of crystallite size and overestimation of strain.

Original question: Using Non-Harmonic reflections in warren averbach method on Chemistry Stack Exchange, licensed CC BY-SA.