Chemistry
Orders of all electronic effects
Step-by-step chemistry solution: Orders of all electronic effects
As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. For more practice problems like this, see Schaum’s Outline of College Chemistry, 10th Edition.
1. Restate the Problem in Plain Language
Organic chemistry often requires us to predict whether a molecule is stable, whether it will react quickly, and where a reaction will take place. These behaviors are largely controlled by how different groups of atoms (substituents) push or pull electron density through a molecule.
This problem asks: How do we determine the relative order (ranking) of these substituent effects—specifically inductive, mesomeric (resonance), hyperconjugative, and electromeric effects—and how do chemists use these effects to rank groups in order of electron-donating or electron-withdrawing strength?
2. Step-by-Step Solution
To determine the relative orders of electronic effects, we must break down what each effect is, establish a hierarchy among them, and understand how they operate in a molecule.
Step 1: Define and Classify the Electronic Effects
Electronic effects are broadly divided into permanent effects (operating continuously in the ground state of a molecule) and temporary effects (operating only in the presence of a reagent).
- Mesomeric Effect ($M$ effect) or Resonance Effect ($R$ effect):
- What it is: The delocalization of $\pi$-electrons (or lone pairs) through conjugation (alternating double and single bonds).
- Nature: Can be electron-donating ($+M$) or electron-withdrawing ($-M$).
- Distance dependence: Operates across the entire conjugated system; does not fall off significantly with distance like the inductive effect.
- Inductive Effect ($I$ effect):
- What it is: The permanent shifting of $\sigma$-electrons along a carbon chain due to electronegativity differences between atoms.
- Nature: Can be electron-withdrawing ($-I$) or electron-donating ($+I$, typically seen in alkyl groups).
- Distance dependence: Distance-dependent. It drops off rapidly and is usually negligible beyond three carbon bonds.
- Hyperconjugation ($H$ effect):
- What it is: The delocalization of $\sigma$-electrons of a $\mathrm{C-H}$ bond (or $\mathrm{C-C}$ bond) into an adjacent empty or partially filled $\pi$-orbital or $p$-orbital (often called “no-bond resonance”).
- Nature: Generally electron-donating.
- Distance dependence: Depends on the number of $\alpha$-hydrogens available on the carbon adjacent to the unsaturated system or carbocation.
- Electromeric Effect ($E$ effect):
- What it is: A temporary effect where a complete transfer of $\pi$-electrons of a multiple bond takes place toward one of the bonded atoms in the presence of an attacking reagent.
- Nature: Operates only during a chemical reaction when a reagent approaches; disappears as soon as the reagent is removed.
Step 2: Establish the General Priority Order (Hierarchy)
When multiple electronic effects operate simultaneously on a molecule and sometimes oppose each other (e.g., an atom has a $-I$ effect but a $+M$ effect), chemists use a strict hierarchical order to determine the net outcome:
\[\mathbf{Mesomeric/Resonance\ (M/R) > Hyperconjugation\ (H) > Inductive\ (I)}\]- Why? Resonance involves the complete overlap of parallel $p$-orbitals, providing a powerful pathway for electron delocalization. Hyperconjugation involves $\sigma$-to-$\pi$ overlap, which is weaker than pure $\pi$-overlap. The inductive effect involves $\sigma$-bond polarization, which is the weakest of the permanent electronic effects.
- Note: The Electromeric ($E$) effect is a temporary polarization and typically overrides permanent effects only at the exact moment of reaction when a strong reagent is present, but for general stability and acidity/basicity rankings in ground states, we rely on $M > H > I$.
Step 3: Rank the Substituents Within Each Effect
To create practical “relative orders” for substituents, chemists rank groups within each specific effect based on fundamental physical properties (like electronegativity and orbital overlap).
A. Ranking the Inductive Effect ($I$)
-
$-I$ (Electron-Withdrawing) Order: Driven by electronegativity and positive charge. Higher positive charge and higher electronegativity increase $-I$ strength. \(\mathrm{-\overset{+}{N}H_3 > -\overset{+}{N}R_3 > -NO_2 > -CN > -SO_3H > -CHO > -COR > -COOH > -F > -Cl > -Br > -I > -OH > -OR > -NH_2 > -C_6H_5 > -H}\)
-
$+I$ (Electron-Donating) Order: Driven by the electron-releasing nature of alkyl groups (often tied to hyperconjugation as well, but treated as $+I$ inductively). More alkyl substitution increases $+I$. \(\mathrm{-C(CH_3)_3 > -CH(CH_3)_2 > -CH_2CH_3 > -CH_3 > -T > -D > -H}\)
B. Ranking the Mesomeric Effect ($M$)
-
$+M$ (Electron-Donating via Resonance) Order: Driven by the presence of lone pairs on the atom directly attached to the conjugated system. Atoms with lower electronegativity donate lone pairs more readily. \(\mathrm{-\mathbf{O}^- > -NH_2 > -NHR > -NR_2 > -OH > -OR > -NHCOR > -OCOR > -F > -Cl > -Br > -I}\) (Halogens are weakly $+M$ by lone-pair donation, though their strong $-I$ usually dominates the overall chemical behavior).
-
$-M$ (Electron-Withdrawing via Resonance) Order: Driven by $\pi$-bonds attached to electronegative atoms connected to the conjugated system. \(\mathrm{-\overset{+}{N}H_3 \text{ (no resonance, purely $-I$)}, \text{ but for resonance:} -NO_2 > -CN > -CHO > -COR > -COOH > -COOR > -CONH_2}\)
C. Ranking Hyperconjugation ($H$)
- Hyperconjugation strength is directly proportional to the number of $\alpha$-hydrogens attached to the $\mathrm{sp^3}$ carbon adjacent to the unsaturated system or carbocation.
- Order of electron-donating power via hyperconjugation: \(\text{Tertiary alkyl ($9\ \alpha\text{-H's}$)} > \text{Secondary alkyl ($6\ \alpha\text{-H's}$)} > \text{Primary alkyl ($3\ \alpha\text{-H's}$)} > \text{Methyl ($0\ \alpha\text{-H's}$)}\)
Step 4: Combine the Effects to Solve Problems
When asked to find the overall electronic effect of a substituent (e.g., in electrophilic aromatic substitution or acidity/basicity comparisons):
- Check for Resonance ($M$): Does the group have lone pairs or multiple bonds conjugated to the system? If yes, $M$ usually dominates.
- Check for Hyperconjugation ($H$): If it is an alkyl group, count $\alpha$-hydrogens.
- Check for Induction ($I$): Evaluate the electronegativity of the attachment atom. Remember that distance matters for $I$, but not for $M$.
- Resolve Conflicts: For example, halogens ($\mathrm{-Cl}$, $\mathrm{-Br}$) have a $-I$ effect (withdrawing electrons inductively) and a $+M$ effect (donating electrons via resonance). Because $M$ usually beats $I$ in conjugated systems, halogens direct ortho/para in benzene chemistry, but because their $-I$ is exceptionally strong, they deactivate the ring overall.
3. Final Answer
To determine the relative orders of electronic effects and the substituents governed by them:
- Hierarchy of Effects: The permanent electronic effects follow the priority order Mesomeric ($M$) > Hyperconjugation ($H$) > Inductive ($I$). The Electromeric ($E$) effect is temporary and acts only during reactions in the presence of a reagent.
- Substituent Ranking within Effects:
- Inductive ($I$): Ranked by atom electronegativity and formal charge (e.g., $-\mathrm{NO_2}$ is strongly $-I$; $-\mathrm{C(CH_3)_3}$ is strongly $+I$).
- Mesomeric ($M$): Ranked by lone-pair availability (for $+M$) or $\pi$-accepting ability with electronegative atoms (for $-M$).
- Hyperconjugation ($H$): Ranked strictly by the number of available $\alpha$-hydrogens ($3^{\circ} > 2^{\circ} > 1^{\circ}$).
- Application: When predicting molecular stability or reactivity, evaluate effects in the order $M \rightarrow H \rightarrow I$, keeping in mind that the Inductive effect drops off rapidly with distance, whereas the Mesomeric effect does not.
4. Common Mistakes
- Confusing the direction of $I$ and $M$ for halogens: Students often assume halogens are purely electron-withdrawing. While they are strongly electron-withdrawing inductively ($-I$), they are weakly electron-donating via resonance ($+M$) due to lone pairs.
- Ignoring distance in the Inductive effect: Students frequently apply $-I$ or $+I$ effects equally across large molecules. Remember that the inductive effect weakens rapidly and is virtually negligible past three $\sigma$-bonds.
- Treating Hyperconjugation as purely inductive: Students often treat alkyl groups as only having a $+I$ effect. In many stabilities (like carbocations and alkenes), hyperconjugation ($H$) is a much more significant stabilizing factor than inductive electron release.
- Misapplying the Electromeric effect: Students often try to rank molecules in ground-state stability (like carbocation or acid strength) using the electromeric ($E$) effect. The $E$ effect is temporary and only applies when a reagent is actively attacking a multiple bond; it plays no role in ground-state thermodynamic stability.
Original question: Orders of all electronic effects on Chemistry Stack Exchange, licensed CC BY-SA.