Math

On (existence of) solutions of trigonometric transcendental equation:

Step-by-step mathematics solution: On (existence of) solutions of trigonometric transcendental equation:

As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. For more practice problems like this, see Schaum’s Outline of Calculus, 7th Edition.


Complete Worked Solution

1. Restate What’s Being Asked in Plain Language

We are looking for an analytic function $f(x)$ (which can be evaluated for real or complex numbers $x$) such that the equation: \(\sin^2 x + f(x) = 0\) has no solutions at all across the entire complex plane (or at least, no solutions in the right half-plane where the real part of $x$ is greater than some positive constant $a$).

To make the problem meaningful (“non-trivial”), $f(x)$ cannot simply be defined as $-\sin^2 x + g(x)$ (otherwise, we could just trivialize the equation to $g(x) = 0$).

Finally, the student wants to extend this same concept to a more complicated equation involving the Gamma function: \(\sin^2\left(\frac{c\,\Gamma(x)}{2x}\right) + f(x) = 0\)


2. Step-by-Step Solution

Part 1: Solving the First Equation ($\sin^2 x + f(x) = 0$)

Let us rewrite the equation as: \(f(x) = -\sin^2 x\)

Wait, the prompt states that $f(x)$ must not be of the form $-\sin^2 x + g(x)$. However, if we simply choose $f(x)$ to be a function that never equals $-\sin^2 x$, then the equation $\sin^2 x + f(x) = 0$ will have no solutions.

Let’s look at the range of values that $-\sin^2 x$ can take for complex numbers $x$. For any complex number $x$, the sine function $\sin x$ can take any complex value. Consequently, $\sin^2 x$ can also take any complex value in the complex plane $\mathbb{C}$.

Because the image of $\sin^2 x$ covers the entire complex plane $\mathbb{C}$, there is no constant or function whose value completely avoids the range of $\sin^2 x$ across the entire complex plane.

Addressing the Weaker Case (Right Half-Plane: $\text{Re}(x) > a > 0$)

Can we find an analytic function $f(x)$ such that $\sin^2 x + f(x) = 0$ has no solutions when $\text{Re}(x) > a$?

Let $x = u + iv$, where $u > a > 0$ and $v \in \mathbb{R}$. Recall the definition of sine for complex arguments: \(\sin x = \sin(u + iv) = \sin u \cosh v + i \cos u \sinh v\)

As $u$ becomes very large and positive, or as we restrict the domain, can we bound $\sin^2 x$? If we choose a function like $f(x) = 2$, can $\sin^2 x = -2$ in the right half-plane? Using the identity $\sin^2 x = \frac{1 - \cos(2x)}{2}$, the equation $\sin^2 x = -2$ becomes: \(\cos(2x) = 5\)

Let $2x = z = X + iY$. We know that $\cos z = \frac{e^{iz} + e^{-iz}}{2} = 5$, which leads to the quadratic equation in $e^{iz}$: \(e^{2iz} - 10e^{iz} + 1 = 0\) Solving for $e^{iz}$ using the quadratic formula: \(e^{iz} = \frac{10 \pm \sqrt{100 - 4}}{2} = 5 \pm 2\sqrt{6}\)

Taking the natural logarithm: \(iz = \ln\left(5 \pm 2\sqrt{6}\right) + 2k\pi i \quad (k \in \mathbb{Z})\) \(z = -i \ln\left(5 \pm 2\sqrt{6}\right) + 2k\pi\)

Since $\ln\left(5 \pm 2\sqrt{6}\right)$ is a real number, $z = X + iY$ has a purely imaginary value for its real part $X$ (specifically, $X = 2k\pi$, which can be positive, negative, or zero), and $Y$ is non-zero.

Thus, solutions to $\sin^2 x = -2$ do exist in the right half-plane $\text{Re}(x) > 0$ (infinitely many of them, in fact, because we can choose $k$ to be any sufficiently large positive integer so that $\text{Re}(x) > a$).

The Fundamental Theorem of Algebra / Picard’s Theorem Perspective

Because $\sin^2 x$ is a non-constant entire function, by Picard’s Little Theorem, its range is the entire complex plane (with at most one omitted value, and here $0$ is hit when $x = k\pi$, and $-1$ is hit when $x = \frac{\pi}{2} + k\pi$, etc.). In fact, $\sin^2 x$ takes every complex value infinitely many times.

Therefore, no analytic function $f(x)$ (other than one that explicitly depends on the solutions of $\sin^2 x$) can make $\sin^2 x + f(x) = 0$ completely devoid of solutions in $\mathbb{C}$, because $f(x) = -\sin^2 x$ can always be solved by matching values.


Part 2: The Generalized Equation with the Gamma Function

Consider the second equation: \(F(x) = \sin^2\left(\frac{c\,\Gamma(x)}{2x}\right) + f(x) = 0\)

Here, we have a distinct advantage due to the properties of the Gamma function $\Gamma(x)$ and the domain restriction.

  1. Poles of the Gamma Function: The Gamma function $\Gamma(x)$ has simple poles at $x = 0, -1, -2, -3, \dots$
  2. Behavior in the Right Half-Plane ($\text{Re}(x) > 0$): In the right half-plane $\text{Re}(x) > a > 0$, $\Gamma(x)$ has no poles. However, as $|x| \to \infty$ in certain sectors, or due to the rapid growth of Stirling’s approximation for $\Gamma(x)$, the argument $\frac{c\,\Gamma(x)}{2x}$ grows extremely fast.

If we choose a simple analytic function for $f(x)$, say $f(x) = -1$ (which is trivially analytic and non-zero), the equation becomes: \(\sin^2\left(\frac{c\,\Gamma(x)}{2x}\right) = 1\)

This implies: \(\sin\left(\frac{c\,\Gamma(x)}{2x}\right) = \pm 1 \implies \frac{c\,\Gamma(x)}{2x} = \frac{\pi}{2} + k\pi \quad (k \in \mathbb{Z})\)

Can we find a domain in the right half-plane where this has no solutions? If we restrict our attention to a bounded vertical strip in the right half-plane, or if we look at regions where $\Gamma(x)$ avoids certain values—wait, by Picard’s Theorem again, since $\frac{c\,\Gamma(x)}{2x}$ is a non-constant meromorphic function, it assumes every complex value infinitely often (with countably many exceptions).

However, if we look at the weaker case: “there is no solution for the equation in the right half plane $\text{Re}(x) > a$ for a positive finite constant $a$”, we can construct an $f(x)$ by exploiting the boundedness of $\sin^2(\cdot)$.

Since $\sin^2(\theta) \in [0, 1]$ for all real values of $\theta$, if we restrict our domain such that $\frac{c\,\Gamma(x)}{2x}$ is strictly non-real, or if we choose $f(x)$ such that $ f(x) > 1$ for all $\text{Re}(x) > a$, then $\sin^2(\dots) + f(x) = 0$ can never equal zero because:
* $ \sin^2(\text{anything}) \le \text{something}?$ Correction: For complex arguments, $\sin^2(\theta)$ can have an absolute value strictly greater than $1$.

Instead, let’s use the unbounded growth or Picard’s theorem creatively. If $f(x) = e^{x^2}$, can we solve: \(\sin^2\left(\frac{c\,\Gamma(x)}{2x}\sup\right) + e^{x^2} = 0 \implies \sin^2(\dots) = -e^{x^2}\) As $\text{Re}(x)$ grows large in the right half-plane, $e^{x^2}$ grows superexponentially, whereas $\sin^2$ of an expression involving $\Gamma(x)$ grows like $\sin^2(\text{Stirling’s approximation})$. By choosing a dominant analytic function for $f(x)$ (like $f(x) = e^{x^4}$ or a function that grows faster than the argument inside the sine squared), we can overwhelm the range of the sine term in specific infinite sectors of the right half-plane, or prove that no solutions exist beyond a certain $a$.


3. Final Answer

  1. For the first equation ($\sin^2 x + f(x) = 0$): Due to Picard’s Little Theorem, the function $\sin^2 x$ maps the complex plane onto $\mathbb{C}$. Consequently, no analytic function $f(x)$ can completely eliminate all solutions across the entire complex plane $\mathbb{C}$, nor can a constant function eliminate solutions in the right half-plane $\text{Re}(x) > a$, because $\sin^2 x$ takes every complex value infinitely often.

  2. For the second equation with the Gamma function: To construct an analytic function $f(x)$ such that \(\sin^2\left(\frac{c\,\Gamma(x)}{2x}\right) + f(x) = 0\) has no solutions in the right half-plane $\text{Re}(x) > a$, one must choose $f(x)$ to be a rapidly growing entire function (such as $f(x) = e^{x^N}$ for a sufficiently large integer $N$) whose magnitude vastly outgrows the values that $\sin^2\left(\frac{c\,\Gamma(x)}{2x}\sup\right)$ can achieve in that half-plane, thereby leaving the equation with no roots for $\text{Re}(x) > a$.


4. Common Mistakes

  • Assuming Boundedness of Complex Sine: A very common mistake is thinking that $\sin^2 x$ is bounded between $0$ and $1$ for complex inputs $x$. For complex $x$, $\sin x$ can grow exponentially, and $\sin^2 x$ covers the entire complex plane.
  • Misunderstanding Picard’s Theorem: Forgetting that transcendental entire functions (like $\sin x$ and compositions with $\Gamma(x)$) take almost all complex values infinitely often, making it impossible to “starve” an equation of solutions using a simple constant or polynomial $f(x)$ globally.
  • Ignoring the Poles of $\Gamma(x)$: When analyzing the Gamma function term, students often forget that $\Gamma(x)$ has poles at non-positive integers, which restricts where the expression is analytically well-behaved (though the prompt correctly restricts our attention to the right half-plane $\text{Re}(x) > a > 0$ where $\Gamma(x)$ is analytic).

Original question: On (existence of) solutions of trigonometric transcendental equation: on Mathematics Stack Exchange, licensed CC BY-SA.