Math

Logic problem: Understanding this question can help explain others

Step-by-step mathematics solution: Logic problem: Understanding this question can help explain others

As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. For more practice problems like this, see Schaum’s Outline of Calculus, 7th Edition.


1. Restating the Question in Plain Language

In formal logic, we are given a compound statement about any two arbitrary people, whom we will call person $A$ and person $B$. We need to figure out what this statement is actually claiming about the real world in everyday, intuitive terms.

Specifically, the statement is an “ “or” “ statement connecting two conditional (“if-then”) clauses:

  1. Clause 1: “If $A$ is Canadian, then $A$ likes hockey.”
  2. Clause 2: “If $B$ is Canadian, then $B$ dislikes hockey.”

We need to break down what it means for the entire disjunction (the “or” statement) to be true for any choice of $A$ and $B$.


2. Step-by-Step Breakdown and Solution

To understand this logic problem completely, we must analyze the components step by step.

Step 1: Translate the statement into symbolic logic

Let’s define our variables:

  • $CA$: “$A$ is Canadian”
  • $HA$: “$A$ likes hockey”
  • $CB$: “$B$ is Canadian”
  • $\sim HB$: “$B$ dislikes hockey” (the negation of $HB$)

The statement has the logical form: \((CA \rightarrow HA) \lor (CB \rightarrow \sim HB)\)

The connective $\lor$ represents an inclusive OR. In logic, an “or” statement is true if at least one of the connected clauses is true (and it is only false if both clauses are false).

Step 2: Analyze what makes a conditional statement ($P \rightarrow Q$) true

In propositional logic, a conditional statement “If $P$, then $Q$” ($P \rightarrow Q$) is only false in one specific scenario: when the premise ($P$) is true, but the conclusion ($Q$) is false. In all other scenarios, the conditional statement is automatically considered true. Specifically:

  • If the premise ($P$) is false, the conditional statement is true (this is known as vacuous truth).
  • If the premise ($P$) is true and the conclusion ($Q$) is true, the conditional statement is true.

Step 3: Analyze the “OR” condition

Since our overall statement is $(CA \rightarrow HA) \lor (CB \rightarrow \sim HB)$, the entire statement is true as long as at least one of the following conditions holds:

  1. $CA \rightarrow HA$ is true.
  2. $CB \rightarrow \sim HB$ is true.

Let’s test what this means for different pairs of people ($A$ and $B$):

  • Scenario 1: Person $A$ is NOT Canadian ($\sim CA$). Because $A$ is not Canadian, the premise of Clause 1 ($CA$) is false. Therefore, the conditional statement $CA \rightarrow HA$ is automatically true. Because at least one part of the “or” statement is true, the entire statement is true.

  • Scenario 2: Person $B$ IS Canadian, but $B$ dislikes hockey ($CB$ is true, and $\sim HB$ is true). Here, the premise of Clause 2 ($CB$) is true, and its conclusion ($\sim HB$) is also true. Therefore, the conditional statement $CB \rightarrow \sim HB$ is true, making the whole statement true.

  • Scenario 3: Person $B$ is NOT Canadian ($\sim CB$). Because $B$ is not Canadian, the premise of Clause 2 ($CB$) is false. Therefore, the conditional statement $CB \rightarrow \sim HB$ is automatically true, making the whole statement true.

  • Scenario 4: Person $A$ IS Canadian, and $A$ likes hockey ($CA$ is true, and $HA$ is true). Here, Clause 1 is true, making the whole statement true.

Step 4: Find the only way the statement could fail (Proof by Contradiction)

When would this statement be false? For an “or” statement to be false, both halves must be false simultaneously:

  1. $(CA \rightarrow HA)$ must be false. This only happens if $A$ is Canadian ($CA$ is true) and $A$ does not like hockey ($HA$ is false).
  2. $(CB \rightarrow \sim HB)$ must be false. This only happens if $B$ is Canadian ($CB$ is true) and $B$ does not dislike hockey (meaning $B$ likes hockey, so $\sim HB$ is false).

Therefore, the statement is only violated if we pick a person $A$ who is a Canadian hockey-hater and a person $B$ who is a Canadian hockey-lover.

Conversely, if we phrase this intuitively: It is impossible to find a Canadian who likes hockey and a Canadian who dislikes hockey at the same time.

Wait, let’s look closer at that. Can both exist in the real world? Yes! There are some Canadians who like hockey and some who don’t. Does that mean the statement fails? Not necessarily, because the statement uses an OR, not an AND.

Let’s re-read the condition for the “OR” statement to succeed. For any two people, at least one of the following must apply:

  • $A$ is not Canadian (or is a hockey-loving Canadian).
  • $B$ is not Canadian (or is a hockey-disliking Canadian).

Put simply: At least one of the two people is either a non-Canadian, a Canadian who likes hockey, or a non-hockey-liking Canadian.

More intuitively translated using material implication equivalents ($P \rightarrow Q \equiv \sim P \lor Q$):

  • $CA \rightarrow HA$ means “$A$ is either not Canadian or likes hockey.”
  • $CB \rightarrow \sim HB$ means “$B$ is either not Canadian or dislikes hockey.”

Connected by an “or”, the statement intuitively means: “At least one of the following is true: either person $A$ is not a Canadian who likes hockey, or person $B$ is not a Canadian who dislikes hockey.”


3. Final Answer

Intuitively, the statement means: For any two people you pick, it is always guaranteed that at least one of them fits the description of either “not being a Canadian who likes hockey” or “not being a Canadian who dislikes hockey.”

Because of how material implication works in logic, this statement is actually a linguistic tautology (always true) in standard logic, meaning you cannot find a pair of people $A$ and $B$ that violates this rule, because the moment $A$ is a Canadian who likes hockey, the first clause is true; the moment $A$ is not that, the definition shifts, ensuring the logic never breaks unless you have a Canadian who likes hockey paired with a Canadian who dislikes hockey while simultaneously denying the conditional truth framework (which classical logic doesn’t allow).

In plainest English: It is impossible to find a pair consisting of a Canadian who loves hockey ($A$) and a Canadian who loves hockey ($B$ — wait, dislikes hockey, $\sim HB$). In short, the statement guarantees that you will never encounter a pairing where $A$ is a Canadian hockey-fan and $B$ is a Canadian hockey-non-fan at the exact same time. (Actually, even if you do, the logic holds because of the “or” structure—making it a statement that is always true by default in classical logic).


4. Common Mistakes

  • Treating the “OR” as an “EXCLUSIVE OR”: Students often think “either [this] or [both]” means the two conditions cannot both be true at the same time. In formal logic, “OR” is inclusive—if both conditional clauses happen to be true, the entire statement is still true.
  • Misunderstanding Conditional Falsehood: A common error is thinking that if person $A$ is not Canadian, the whole question becomes “invalid” or “N/A.” In logic, if the premise ($P$) of an “if-then” statement is false, the entire conditional statement is automatically considered true.
  • Confusing “Dislikes Hockey” with “Not Canadian”: Mixing up the negations ($\sim HB$ means $B$ dislikes hockey, not that $B$ fails to be Canadian) during substitution steps.

Original question: Logic problem: Understanding this question can help explain others on Mathematics Stack Exchange, licensed CC BY-SA.